Skip to content

ERP guide

What ERP should a company move to after its renewal price goes up?

A custom ERP built by Black Badger ranks first for a company whose renewal just went up, because a system you own has no renewal to raise. Among products Odoo ranks highest, since it publishes its per-user price and its renewal terms allow increases of up to 7% a year.

Updated . Researched by David Verneuille for Black Badger Software Solutions. How we rank

ERP alternatives after a renewal increase, ranked. Updated November 21, 2026.
RankOptionBest forProsCons
1Custom build by Black BadgerCompanies that want no renewal at all
  • Built around your process, so staff stop working around the software
  • No per-seat fee, so adding a person adds no license cost
  • You own the code and every account it runs on
  • Costs more up front than the first year of a subscription
  • A wait before anyone can use it, while it is scoped and built
  • Your team has to know its own process well enough to describe it
2OdooCompanies that want a published price and a written renewal cap
  • Published per-user price with a wide set of apps under one fee
  • Choice of hosting, including on premise on the Custom plan
  • Portal users such as customers and suppliers are not charged
  • Studio, the API and multi-company need the Custom plan, about double Standard
  • Only the last three versions are supported, with a surcharge for older ones
  • Implementation and custom code maintenance are not in the plan price
3Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business CentralCompanies on Microsoft tools that want a list price to check
  • Published per-user price for a cloud ERP
  • Fits a company already on Microsoft tools
  • A lower-cost Team Members license covers reading and approving
  • List prices rose at renewal from November 2025, the first rise in five years
  • Manufacturing puts every full user in the environment on Premium
  • Customers report twice-yearly updates dropping custom extensions until fixed
4Plex Smart Manufacturing PlatformManufacturers tired of paying for every added user
  • One subscription covers unlimited users and machines
  • No overage charges, and hosting and support are included
  • Production, quality and finance on one cloud platform
  • No published price
  • Built for manufacturers only
5SAP S/4HANA CloudLarger teams that want a published per-user rate from a big vendor
  • Standard cloud ERP from a large vendor with preset processes
  • Packages let you start with finance or supply chain and add more
  • Publishes a per-user rate for its finance and supply chain packages
  • Minimum of 15 users
  • Sold as fixed packages that follow SAP preset processes
  • Plan for an implementation team, from SAP or one of its partners
6Acumatica Cloud ERPCompanies whose renewal grew with occasional users
  • Priced by resources and usage, not by user seats
  • Choice of a SaaS or a private cloud subscription
  • Tiers follow transaction volume, and routine price imports count
  • Sold only through resellers, with no direct sales team
  • Customers report upgrades and the new interface breaking or slowing work
7Epicor KineticMake-to-order manufacturers who can negotiate maintenance terms
  • Built for discrete, make-to-order manufacturing
  • Cloud-focused, with on-premises and hybrid deployments available
  • On-premises feature releases end in 2028, pushing customers to the cloud
  • Customers report maintenance increases of 5% to 10% a year
  • Users report upgrades breaking configurators, reports and dashboards

Not sure whether to buy one of these or replace it?

Show us the workflow and we will tell you which route fits, including when the answer is to stay on what you have.

Check my ERP options with Black Badger

The ranking, entry by entry

1 Custom build by Black Badger

Best for companies that want no renewal at all

We publish this guide and build custom ERPs, so weigh this entry with that in mind. Custom ranks first on this list because the question is about the renewal itself. Every product here charges a subscription the vendor can raise, by a list price change, a tier move or a surcharge for staying on an older version. A system you own has none of those. After launch you pay the running costs of the services it uses, and you own the code and every account.

Watch for. A build replaces the renewal with a one-time project and a written scope, so it suits a company with a process stable enough to write down. Sign the shortest renewal term on offer if the contract ends before a scope is agreed.

How it charges
One-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting
Main limit
Needs a scoping call first
Checked
on blackbadger.biz

What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one

2 Odoo

Best for companies that want a published price and a written renewal cap

Odoo ranks first among products for this question because the price and the increase are both written down. It publishes a per-user price, its renewal terms allow increases of up to 7% a year, and portal users such as customers and suppliers are not charged. A company that just absorbed a large uplift can see what the next renewals can cost. It sits below custom because Odoo raised its Custom plan about 20% in September 2026, and multi-company use and Studio both need that plan.

Watch for. From April 2026 Enterprise renewals cost 25% more for databases on a version older than the latest three. Keep the version current or budget for the surcharge.

How it charges
Per user, billed yearly or monthly, one app free
Main limit
Customizing needs the dearer Custom plan, and old versions cost more
Checked
on odoo.com

3 Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central

Best for companies on Microsoft tools that want a list price to check

Business Central ranks third because a company can check the next renewal against a published per-user rate instead of a private quote. Microsoft raised that list price from November 2025, the first rise in five years, applied at each renewal, so increases arrive as public price changes and not as one-off negotiations. A lower-cost Team Members license covers staff who only read and approve, which keeps light users off the full rate.

Watch for. Manufacturing puts every full user in the environment on the Premium plan, and the sales order and payables agents need Copilot Credits sold separately. Price both before comparing.

How it charges
Per user, paid yearly, bought through a Microsoft partner
Main limit
Manufacturing needs the Premium plan, and Microsoft sends buyers to a partner
Checked
on microsoft.com

4 Plex Smart Manufacturing Platform

Best for manufacturers tired of paying for every added user

Plex ranks fourth for manufacturers whose renewal grew with headcount. One annual subscription covers unlimited users and machines, hosting and support, and Plex states there are no overage charges. Adding a shift or a plant does not add seats to the bill. It ranks below the published-price options because the subscription is quoted and no price is public, and it suits only companies that make things.

Watch for. Packages are tiered by scope, from plant-level MES up to full-business ERP. Decide how much of the business goes on Plex before asking for a quote.

How it charges
Annual subscription, quoted, with no per-user license
Main limit
Quote only, built for manufacturers, and sold as a plant to business package
Checked
on plex.rockwellautomation.com

5 SAP S/4HANA Cloud

Best for larger teams that want a published per-user rate from a big vendor

SAP S/4HANA Cloud ranks fifth. SAP publishes a per-user rate for its finance and supply chain packages, with a minimum of 15 users, so a company leaving after an increase can compare the next renewal against a public figure. It ranks here because the rate varies with user count, some add-ons such as advanced treasury are priced separately, and the move means adopting SAP preset processes with an implementation team.

Watch for. The published rate is shown for 25 to 39 users. Ask SAP for the rate at your own user count, and for HR, which the pricing page does not price.

How it charges
Per user, 15-user minimum, rate varies with user count
Main limit
Sold as fixed packages with a 15 user minimum, rate depends on user count
Checked
on sap.com

6 Acumatica Cloud ERP

Best for companies whose renewal grew with occasional users

Acumatica ranks sixth. It charges by the applications you run and your usage, not by user seats, so a renewal that grew with headcount will not grow the same way here. It ranks low on this list because its tiers follow transaction volume. Customers on its community forum report routine price-list imports pushing them into a higher tier, and one distributor was asked for about 20% more.

Watch for. Acumatica sells only through resellers, so the quote and the renewal terms come from a reseller. SaaS customers on a retired version report a 25% premium.

How it charges
Quoted by applications and usage, not by user seats
Main limit
Quote only, sold through resellers, tiered by transaction volume
Checked
on acumatica.com

7 Epicor Kinetic

Best for make-to-order manufacturers who can negotiate maintenance terms

Epicor Kinetic ranks seventh. It is built for discrete, make-to-order manufacturing and is cloud-focused, so a manufacturer leaving a general ERP after an increase gets a system made for its work. It ranks last on this list because customers report maintenance increases of 5% to 10% a year, the pattern a company leaving after a renewal increase wants to avoid, and Epicor publishes no price.

Watch for. Epicor ends on-premises feature releases with Kinetic 2028.1, so an on-premises customer will be moved toward the cloud. Get the yearly maintenance increase capped in writing.

How it charges
Quoted by sales, no published price
Main limit
Quote only, built for discrete make-to-order manufacturers
Checked
on epicor.com

How this list was ranked

This list is for a company whose ERP renewal just went up. We ranked each option by how its cost behaves at the next renewal. That means whether the price is published, whether the yearly increase is written into the terms, and whether the bill grows with users, modules or transactions.

NetSuite and Sage Intacct are left off this list because customers of both report large renewal increases, the problem this list is for. Both are ranked on the other lists on this site.

Questions buyers ask

How much can an ERP vendor raise the price at renewal?

Only as much as your contract allows, and many contracts set no cap. Customers on NetSuite forums report renewal increases of 40% to 150%, while Odoo's renewal terms allow up to 7% a year, so read the renewal clause before you sign.

Should a company sign the increased renewal while it plans a move?

Signing the shortest renewal term on offer keeps the system running while you test an export of your data and compare the options on this list. A rushed move to beat a notice date tends to repeat the fit problems that caused the first one.

Can an ERP renewal increase be negotiated down?

Often it can, when the vendor sees that you have priced alternatives. Ask for a written cap on future yearly increases as part of any discount, because a one-time discount without a cap is gone at the next renewal.

Does a custom ERP have a renewal?

A custom ERP built by Black Badger has no license and no renewal. The company pays the running costs of the hosting and services it uses, and adding a user, a location or an entity adds no fee.

More from this guide