ERP guide
Should you stay on Business Central or move to a custom ERP?
Stay on Business Central when your company runs on Microsoft tools, fits the standard Essentials processes and has a partner it trusts. Move to a custom ERP when licenses, Premium upgrades, AppSource apps and the partner work that keeps extensions running cost more each year than a system you own would cost to build and run.
| What you are comparing | Staying on Business Central | A custom build |
|---|---|---|
| Renewals and add-ons | A published per-user price, paid yearly, which Microsoft raised at renewal from November 2025. AppSource apps and the Copilot Credits its AI agents use are billed on top. | A one-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting. Nothing renews, and the features you need are part of the build. |
| User licenses and Premium | No charge per company, but each full user needs a license. Manufacturing needs Premium, and Premium then applies to every full user in the environment. | No per-user fee and no tiers. A new hire, a new site or a new company adds no license. |
| API limits and storage | Microsoft throttles API requests per user and caps database storage per tenant, so a busy integration or a growing database can reach a limit. | Limits come from the hosting you choose, and you can see and raise them. |
| Getting your data out | No direct SQL access in the cloud. A full database export goes to your own Azure storage, at most 10 per environment a month, run by an admin. | The database is on accounts you own, so a full export or a direct query is available whenever you need it. |
| Support and updates | Support and purchases go through your Microsoft partner. Customers report the twice-yearly updates dropping custom extensions until the partner fixes them. | Black Badger or any competent developer maintains it, and changes ship when you approve them after testing. |
| Fit to your process | Standard finance and operations processes, extended with AppSource apps or custom extensions that have to stay compatible with each Microsoft release. | Built from your process, so the approvals, pricing rules and handoffs your team works around today are part of the system. |
When staying on Business Central is the right call
Stay when Business Central fits without much custom code. A company on Essentials that uses the standard processes, adds few extensions and works mostly in Microsoft tools has a vendor-run system at a published price, and the November 2025 increase does not change that.
Stay when you have a partner who answers quickly and keeps your extensions current, and when your growth comes from adding companies more than adding users, since Business Central does not charge per company. And stay if your team cannot yet describe the process a replacement would follow, because a custom build starts from that description.
What leaving Business Central involves
Leaving starts with getting the data out on Microsoft's terms. There is no direct SQL access in the cloud, so the full record comes from a database export to your own Azure storage, which an admin can run at most 10 times per environment a month, or through the API, which Microsoft throttles per user. Plan the extract early and test it against your trial balance and inventory valuation.
Then every extension and AppSource app has to be accounted for. List what each one does, decide whether the new system needs it, and confirm that reports, approvals and integrations produce the same results before cutover. A sound plan runs at least one period close in both systems, switches at the start of a fiscal period, and keeps the exported history where auditors can reach it.
How a cloud custom build replaces Business Central
A custom ERP is a web application on cloud hosting you own, built around how your company sells, buys, makes and accounts for things. Black Badger starts with discovery and a written scope that lists every process, report, approval and integration the system must handle, and the price comes from that scope.
The custom extensions you pay a partner to maintain are often the best guide to the scope, because each one marks a place where the product did not fit. A custom system builds those in from the start, with no Premium tier, no per-user license and no update schedule set by a vendor. You own the code, the database and every account it runs on, and it can still connect to the Microsoft 365 tools your staff use.
What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one
Questions buyers ask
When does a custom ERP cost less than Business Central?
A custom ERP costs less than Business Central when, over five years, the licenses, Premium upgrades, AppSource apps and partner fees for extensions add up to more than building and running your own system. Compare the five-year totals, not the first-year license against a build. A company with few users and few extensions usually finds Business Central cheaper.
Can I export everything from Business Central online?
Microsoft allows a full database export from the admin center to your own Azure storage, at most 10 per environment a month, and does not support restoring that export to an on-premises server. Without direct SQL access, the other route is the API, which Microsoft throttles per user. Treat the export as its own step in any move.
Do Business Central updates break custom extensions?
Customers report that the twice-yearly major updates can drop a custom extension from the update until its code is fixed, and Microsoft says the extension publisher must keep it compatible with each release. A company with many extensions pays a partner for that work every update cycle, which is one of the costs to count before renewing.
Can a custom ERP keep working with Microsoft 365?
A custom ERP can connect to Microsoft 365, so staff keep signing in with their Microsoft accounts and keep working in Outlook, Excel and Teams. The connections are scoped like any other integration, and the data lives in a database you own instead of a Microsoft tenant.
More from this guide
- Top picks
- After a renewal increase
- Multi-entity companies
- NetSuite alternatives
- Acumatica alternatives
- Sage Intacct alternatives
- Business Central alternatives
- Dynamics GP alternatives
- SAP Business One alternatives
- Epicor alternatives
- Odoo alternatives
- Salesforce alternatives
- HubSpot alternatives
- Leaving NetSuite?
- Leaving Acumatica?
- Leaving Sage Intacct?
- Leaving Dynamics GP?
- Leaving SAP Business One?
- Leaving Epicor?
- Leaving Odoo?
- Leaving Salesforce?
- Leaving HubSpot?
- Custom option