ERP guide
Should a company leave SAP Business One or stay on it?
Staying on SAP Business One is reasonable while your release is under SAP maintenance and your reseller, add-ons and integrations still work. Leave when the yearly maintenance, the reseller and the add-ons around Business One cost more than they return, and a cloud custom build or a product such as Oracle NetSuite will fit how you work.
| What you are comparing | Staying on SAP Business One | A custom build |
|---|---|---|
| Maintenance end | SAP's own maintenance page lists December 31, 2028 as the end of maintenance for release 10.0, and SAP offers no extended maintenance for Business One. | No vendor end date. You own the code and every account it runs on. |
| Servers and hosting | Business One runs on SQL Server or SAP HANA, on your servers or a reseller's, and remote access to the desktop client has often meant Citrix or remote desktop licenses. | Built and run in the cloud on accounts you own, reached from a browser. Black Badger installs nothing on your site. |
| Upgrades | Customers report upgrades breaking add-ons and screens, and some features, such as cash-flow forecasting, need the HANA database. | Changes are made when you ask for them and tested against your own process, with no vendor release to follow. |
| Integrations | Customers report that connecting other systems through the DI API needs an indirect access user license, which SAP does not price publicly. | Connections to other systems are part of the build, with no license for each connection. |
| Getting data out | Customers report that customizations and add-on data do not move with the records, and the Data Transfer Workbench only imports. | Your data stays in a database on an account you own, readable and exportable at any time. |
| Fit to process | Business One has no HR or payroll, and customers report paying for add-ons to fill gaps such as production scheduling, and running each company in its own database. | Built from your process, including the scheduling, approvals and multi-company rules that Business One needed add-ons for. |
| How each route is paid for | A perpetual license per named user plus yearly maintenance billed by the reseller, or a cloud subscription through the reseller. SAP publishes no price list. | A one-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting and support. No licenses and no maintenance fee on a license. |
| Support | Support runs through your reseller, and customers report waiting for the contract year to change resellers. | A named owner on your side, with Black Badger or any competent developer maintaining code that is written to be read and extended. |
When staying on SAP Business One is the right call
Stay when Business One runs your company well, your release is under SAP maintenance and your reseller answers. SAP's own maintenance page dates the end of maintenance for each release, so check where yours sits before planning anything.
Stay too when the complaints are about reports and screens and not the system. A reporting tool on top of Business One is a smaller change than a new ERP.
What leaving SAP Business One involves
List the add-ons, user-defined fields, queries and Crystal Reports the company depends on, since none of them move to another system as they are. Then decide how much history to bring, and run the old and new systems together through a month-end close before Business One is switched off.
Read the reseller contract before you start. Customers report that leaving or changing resellers follows the contract year, and the yearly maintenance bill on a perpetual license arrives at a fixed point in that year.
How a cloud custom build replaces SAP Business One
Black Badger starts with discovery of how orders, stock and money move today, including what each Business One add-on was bought to do. The scope that follows names what the custom system replaces and what it connects to. The system is built in the cloud on accounts the company owns, and nothing is installed on site.
Business One keeps its data in SQL Server or SAP HANA, so the history can be read out and loaded on a plan set in the scope. Payroll, which Business One never had, stays with the provider the company already uses and is connected to the new system.
What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one
Questions buyers ask
When does SAP stop maintaining SAP Business One 10.0?
SAP's own maintenance page lists December 31, 2028 as the end of maintenance for SAP Business One 10.0, and older SAP pages gave an earlier date. SAP offers no extended maintenance for Business One, so check the release your company runs against SAP's page and plan the move or the upgrade before that date.
Why do SAP Business One customers go through a reseller for support?
SAP sells and supports Business One through its resellers, so customers open support cases with the reseller and not with SAP. Customers report that changing resellers can wait for the contract year, so a company leaving Business One should read its reseller contract first.
Can Black Badger move SAP Business One to the cloud for us?
Black Badger does not host, resell or maintain SAP Business One. Black Badger builds a custom system in the cloud that replaces Business One, and the company's data is read out of the Business One database and loaded into it under a written scope.
Is a custom ERP a fit for a small SAP Business One company?
A custom ERP fits a small Business One company when its process is specific enough that it already pays for add-ons, a reseller and workarounds to make Business One fit. A company that runs Business One close to standard is usually better served by a cloud product such as Acumatica or NetSuite.
More from this guide
- Top picks
- After a renewal increase
- Multi-entity companies
- NetSuite alternatives
- Acumatica alternatives
- Sage Intacct alternatives
- Business Central alternatives
- Dynamics GP alternatives
- SAP Business One alternatives
- Epicor alternatives
- Odoo alternatives
- Salesforce alternatives
- HubSpot alternatives
- Leaving NetSuite?
- Leaving Acumatica?
- Leaving Sage Intacct?
- Leaving Business Central?
- Leaving Dynamics GP?
- Leaving Epicor?
- Leaving Odoo?
- Leaving Salesforce?
- Leaving HubSpot?
- Custom option